Driving home from work this morning, I was thinking back to a piece I wrote back in 2017. Six months into his term, I wrote an essay on Trump and why I thought that he was “The president America rightly deserves“. When I got home and re-read it, I felt that it needed to be updated a bit. Although, I still have my reasons to believe that Trump is exactly the president that America deserves to have in office right now, I feel that it’s more important that Republicans need Trump. They desperately need someone like Trump in office right now, but it’s likely not for the reasons you’d think. Give me a minute to explain.
Whether they want to admit it or not, most Republicans and conservatives are in quite a pickle right now. The overwhelming support for Trump directly contradicts the image the GOP has tried to cultivate for itself over the past generation as the staunch defenders of the Constitution and American way of life. Remember the pocket Constitutions that Republicans used to carry and wave around as props? Where are they now? Have you seen any of them hold one up to view since January 20, 2017?
Trump is the perfect test case for testing the limits of political power vs Constitutional authority and norms. Since he’s taken office, Constitutional norms have disappeared from the GOP lexicon. The GOP-controlled Congress ceded their Constitutional authority and power to allow Trump to do as he pleased with no push back at all. As a result of that, we see Trump’s former lawyer heading to prison for lying to that same GOP-controlled Congress over issues that appear to show that Trump may have broken laws after he took the oath of office as well as before that time. Now, some of those same Republicans want to cry foul over the moves made by the Democratic-controlled House to investigate these potential violations.
Most recently, we’re hearing that Trump ordered his daughter and son-in-law to receive security clearances after background investigations flagged them both as not meeting the necessary requirements to be granted those clearances. I’ll be the first to admit that the president does have that authority to grant those clearances in that instance. Considering the current president AND his party made the 2016 election all about classified information security, you would think caution would be the play in this case as opposed to giving a finger to the process that’s been in place to guard our secrets.
Hillary Clinton’s emails? Give me an effin’ break about that now. That dog won’t hunt. Reality Winner’s leak? So much for that one too, huh? Edward Snowden? Bradley/Chelsea Manning? The list goes on and on in regards to security clearances and violators. Now, Trump has turned the whole security clearance process into a joke. There was even wide reporting on how some countries sought to leverage knowledge on Kushner to help with their negotiations. God only knows if we’ll pay dearly for this one.
Even beyond the security clearance issue, there the Emoluments Clause to deal with. Don’t forget the Muslim ban. There’s the immigration “emergency” which led to parent/child separations at the border as well as the recent emergency declaration to reallocate funding to build a wall on the southern border. On the horizon, there’s the issue with Hoda Muthana’s citizenship and whether she will be allowed to return to the US and face justice over her actions.
Republicans long portrayed themselves as defenders of the Constitution and the party of competent governance. We’ve all heard about their fiscal stewardship and other things. We’ve listened to them warn about the socialism and other boogeymen we’d face if we did not keep them in control of the government. All of that is garbage when you look at how the GOP has abandoned the Constitution altogether and turned to Trumpism. I saw the GOP as completely giving up on the Constitution as soon as they decided to go along with Trump’s emergency declaration for the wall. They were already turning their backs to the document, but that cemented the deal.
Donald Trump is exactly what the GOP needs now. They are at a crossroad where they have to decide on whether they love the Constitution or whether they love Trump. There is not room for both, especially considering how Trump has behaved thus far while in office. If I felt that Trump was able to change, I wouldn’t see this as an either-or choice for Republicans. There was evidence before the election to point out that Trump wasn’t fit to be president, but they voted him into office anyway. Now the country, especially Republicans, have to deal with this.
Just as the dilemma posed in the short story “The Lady, or the Tiger?”, Republicans are facing two stark and distinct choices. Unlike the lead in that story, the GOP has a clear view of their choices and the ramifications of their choice. The moral dilemma boils down to whether they want power or sound governance.