Why do we need to legalize discrimination

Why is there such a mad push between the states to legalize discrimination?  There are several states that have either passed or are in the process of passing bills that basically legalize discrimination against the LGBT community.  These bills all share a common theme and almost bear the same name.  Arizona’s Senate Bill 1062 “Exercise of Religion”, Georgia’s House Bill 1023 “Preservation of Religious Freedom Act”, and Kansas’ House Bill 2453 “Religious Freedom Act” all check in at 3 pages of text.  The text of the bills almost read exactly alike as well.  Couched as bills intended to protect religious freedoms, they all have the basic effect of legalizing discrimination against the LGBT community and any other groups that people can claim some type of religious objection to serving.

My first thought is these types of bills are stupid as hell, and they are quite unconstitutional.  This country has danced with discrimination several times, and discrimination has never won.  Why waste time and energy doing the same thing and expecting a different outcome?  This country is supposed to be all about freedom, and we all enjoy the freedoms that come with being a citizen of the United States.  One may think that these laws enable freedom to express religious beliefs, but all they do is give legal cover to discriminate with impunity.

Reading the text of the bills (links provided above), they are written so broadly that they go far beyond discrimination against the LGBT community as most of the uproar has been about.  Reading carefully, an EMT could legally be covered for refusing to provide emergency services to an accident victim by claiming a religious objection to providing medical services to that person.  Reading Georgia’s text, it looks like one could even claim religious cover from imposing criminal or civil penalties if it interferes with the exercise of religion.

This man’s opinion is that none of these laws are necessary.  There’s a simple solution to this without the need for unnecessary regulations, which I thought conservatives were against in the first place.  If you don’t want to serve a particular community, then don’t enter into business with them or sign contracts to provide a service.  Place a big assed sign in your front window that says who you refuse to serve due to your beliefs.  There are people who will frequent your business because of that, and there are those who won’t give you a freakin’ dime.  There’s no need for lawsuits or anything else.  If your beliefs are true and sincere, then your God will ensure your business will succeed.  If you are running afoul of your God, then I’m sure he will administer punishment for that as well.  Case closed.

With these kinds of laws, it seems as though nobody thinks of the unintended consequences of enacting such legislation until those unintended consequences appear and start to bite them on the ass.  In Arizona, there are three Republican Senators who voted for their law and now want the governor to veto it.

Three Republican senators who voted for Senate Bill 1062 say they made a bad decision in a rushed process and are now asking Gov. Jan Brewer to veto the right to refuse service bill.

“We feel it was a solution in search of a problem,” Sen. Bob Worsley, R-Mesa, said in an impromptu news conference outside the state Senate. He was joined by Sen. Steve Pierce, R-Prescott.

The two, along with Senate Majority Whip Adam Driggs, R-Phoenix, sent Brewer a letter Monday morning asking for a veto.

“While our sincere intent in voting for this bill was to create a shield for all citizens’ religious liberties, the bill has instead been mischaracterized by its opponents as a sword for religious intolerance,” the three wrote. “These allegations are causing our state immeasurable harm.”

The bill has not been mischaracterized at all.  What has happened is that people are realizing the implications of the law and don’t like what they see.  The business community in Arizona is already looking at lost dollars from people who are boycotting the state as a result of this law.  You would think that Arizona has had enough of the controversial laws with the boycotts over the MLK holiday issue and the “papers please” law.  Some people just don’t know how to leave well enough alone.  Now, Georgia and Kansas Republicans are trying to outdo Arizona.

Another possible issue that may arise is that the very people who have been crying about Sharia Law may actually pave the way for it to be legally enshrined in law.  All it takes is for one Muslim to have a case where they claim their religious freedoms are being violated by not being able to practice Sharia, and what can the states passing these laws do?  Absolutely nothing in some cases.  If you read the last sentence in Georgia’s House Bill, it reads, “All laws and parts of laws in conflict with this Act are repealed.”  That means that this law, if enacted, would supersede any previous laws on the books.  There are Muslims whose sincerest religious beliefs include Sharia and all that encompasses it.  The people pushing these bills are the same people who get nervous as hell when a Islamic group petitions to build or open a mosque.  The law of unintended consequences can pack a mean punch when people fail to think things through.

Are these Conservative Christians going to be okay with niqabs and burkas being worn all around the place here?

In this day and age, we should not have elected officials who are wasting our time and money on crap like this.  Discrimination has continuously been ruled unconstitutional.  We went through this with slavery, women’s suffrage, and Jim Crow amongst other instances of discrimination.  Why we need to do this again is beyond me.  Our politicians have a habit of sticking their noses into the affairs of other sovereign nations and castigating them for discriminatory policies.  Some of these same people, or their colleagues, are doing what they’ve told others not to do.

Nobody’s religion is under attack in America.  There is no massive campaign to allow anyone to not express their religious beliefs.  All recognized religions in this country have the same equal protection under the Constitution, and our government rightly does not advocate or prefer any one religion over the others.  I don’t try to tell others how to express their religion, but I don’t think expressing your religion calls for forcing your beliefs onto other people, including those who don’t share your belief system.  These politicians need to leave well enough alone.

Enhanced by Zemanta

3 thoughts on “Why do we need to legalize discrimination

  1. Because there seem to be so MANY people hell-bent on practicing it?

    Okay, now that I’ve guessed at the answer to the title question, I’ll go read the article.


  2. I think this is Republican group-think. Todd Starnes wrote a weepy editorial last summer about the poor Oregon couple who just want to run their bakery according to their beliefs whose business is now being ruined by all the bad publicity about their turning away a gay couple who wanted a wedding cake. (Fox doesn’t publish email addresses or any way to get in touch with their commentators or I would have certainly told him I well remembered that same story from Georgia business owners in the ’60s who just wanted to run their businesses according to their Christian beliefs that black people were of the race of Ham.) I’m guessing someone like the Family Research Council must have picked up that ball and run with it, writing the bill and pushing it out to Republicans on their mailing lists.

    I actually don’t think businesses should be allowed to say who they won’t serve, other than no shoes, no shirt, no service. However, I certainly agree that if there are people they don’t want to serve, they should make their feelings known. If I saw a sign in the window that said, “We run our business according to our Christian values,” I’d know this was a business I didn’t want to give my money to.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s