Labor battle royale

There’s a battle brewing on the horizon, and it may be much more significant than many people would ever think.  Earlier this week, the National Labor Relations Board filed a formal complaint against Wal-Mart Stores for actions related to protests held against the company on Black Friday.

From Wall Street Cheat

A formal complaint filed Wednesday revealed that Wal-Mart Stores may be navigating legal drama in the near future on account of its actions in response to a strike in 2012 orchestrated by union-backed group OUR Walmart. Black Friday has long been a big day for retailers, but it was an especially epic — and not in a good way — day for Wal-Mart in 2012 ,when workers across 46 states walked off the job and participated in legally protected activities to campaign for higher wages and better working conditions.

One year later, the dust has settled, but Wal-Mart may still face consequences for the way it responded to its employees’ actions in 2012.  The Associated Press reported Wednesday that federal officials filed a formal complaint this week, charging the nation’s largest retailer with violating the rights of workers and illegally firing, disciplining, or threatening its employees who participated in the Black Friday strike.

Wal-Mart workers struck on Black Friday again in 2013, although the number of participating employees was not as significant. Wal-Mart has shown no hesitation about letting disgruntled employees go, but the NLRB alleges that the company illegally fired 19 workers on account of their participation in the 2012 strike. The complaint also states that Wal-Mart unlawfully threatened, disciplined, or terminated workers for participating in strikes and protests in California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, North Carolina, Ohio, Texas, and Washington.

The reason the NLRB’s actions may be a bit more than what most people think is because the NLRB is filing this complaint on behalf of non-union member workers.  As this country has seen union membership dwindle, there will be more and more cases of the NLRB representing non-union workers in complaints against employers.  The outcome of these cases will likely determine the future course of this country in regards to organized labor.

“This is part of a drive by the NLRB to further police employees’ labor rights in the non-unionized workforce,” said Paul Secunda, a professor of labor law at Marquette University.

“If the NLRB can go after Wal-Mart and be successful, that sends a shot across the bow to all employers across the line – to employers that are similar in size, to smaller employers – that they are under the jurisdiction of the NLRB,” he said.

In addition, the Wal-Mart case weaves together complaints on behalf of 19 fired workers, as opposed to handling one complaint at a time. That makes it “precedent-setting,” said Sarita Gupta of Jobs With Justice, a workers’ rights group.

“A victory for the board and the union could have symbolic importance for unionizing drives across the country,” said Michael Gold, a professor of labor law at Cornell University.

“Just the opposite is true – if Wal-Mart wins the case, they are really going to trumpet it. They are going to tell their workers, with good cause, ‘we did not break the law. The government persecuted us for nothing,'” he said.

Wal-Mart has until January 28th to respond.  After that, the case will go before an administrative law judge.  I find it very unlikely that Wal-Mart would decide to settle the case out of court, so this will likely be a case to follow for the next year or two while it works its way through the court system.

Over the past 40 years, this country has seen wages stagnate, the middle class start to shrink, and union membership dwindle while the top 10% of income earners have reaped most of the rewards for the economic expansion in this country.  I think that the destruction of organized labor plays a part of this along with the monetization of our economy.  We’ve also gone from a manufacturing based economy to a service based one within that same time span.  If the corporations themselves are not willing to look at the pay structure and reward workers accordingly for the increased production with fewer workers, they are ultimately going to push American workers back to the point where unionization will appear to be the only method of seeking relief.  Sometimes, you can fight so hard against something that you wind up making it happen anyway.  This may be one of those cases.



Enhanced by Zemanta

3 thoughts on “Labor battle royale

  1. Be interesting to see where this goes. If WalMart loses I would image it’ll eventually wind up in the Supreme Court. It’s anybody’s guess what would happen there.

    It’s been quite a few years ago but I remember a TV interview with George Will (hardly a left-winger) and he was making the case that he thought people who thought high wages were bad for the U.S. were wrong. He made the case that the period when the U.S. had the highest wages, the 60’s, was when the economy was at its strongest. High wages gave people the money to buy things and keep it rolling. I don’t think that was the sole factor in the economic strength but it played a large part in it.

    In my view, those who want to keep working class wages down are cutting off their nose to spite their face.


    • I’m gonna make a note to myself to keep up with it. That interview would be interesting to see if for nothing else but to see if he’s changed his viewpoint.

      I don’t understand why everyone doesn’t fight harder for better wages. It’s the bottom 60% that spends to keep the economy moving. If the amount to spend keeps decreasing, we will reach the point where the whole house collapses in on itself.

      I don’t even think we need unions to the extent that we had before. The Germans have a system where workers are represented by unions and the unions have representation on the board making decisions for the company. Labor and management work together to ensure everyone wins instead of doing the American thing and fighting each other for the same nickel.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s